Jane vs. Phoebe?
Throughout The Catcher in the Rye, Holden repeatedly expresses his idealization of purity and innocence of childhood and hatred for the phoniness of adulthood. Holden defines purity as untainted by adulthood’s corruption and phoniness. In Holden’s four days wandering in the streets of New York City, he dismisses almost everyone he meets as phony for their hypocrisy, vanity, conceit, or whatever it may be. Among the few free from his criticisms are Jane Gallagher and his sister, Phoebe Caulfield. While they are both emotional support for Holden, he classifies them into very different roles in his psychological world. Jane symbolizes Holden’s attachment to the lost, idealized childhood, while Phoebe emerges as a living guiding force grounding him in the mental breakdown. Jane is Holden’s close childhood friend and neighbor. Throughout the book, Jane exists entirely in Holden’s memory, frozen and unattainable in the ideal past. Holden idealizes Jane for her innocence and childishness. In...